This paper examines the effect of accounting restatements on a firms cost of equity capital. Botosan 1997 investigates the effect of the corporate disclosure level on the cost of equity capital by regressing firmspecific estimates of costof equity capital on. Furthermore, the cost of equity capital in this study describes two sides. Disclosure and the cost of equity capital semantic scholar. Depending on the model used, relative percentage increases in the cost of equity capital average between 7 and 19% in the month immediately following. We demonstrate that the quality of accounting information can influence the cost of capital, both directly and indirectly. These results confirm and extend the results of botosan 1997 to include. Botosan, ca and ma plumlee 2002 a reexamination of disclosure level and the expected cost of equity capital. Based on a production economy with perfect competition among investors, the analysis demonstrates three points. Pdf impact of corporate disclosure on cost of equity. The impact of voluntary corporate disclosures on the ex. Botosan 1997 investigates the effect of the corporate disclosure level on the cost of equity capital by regressing firmspecific estimates of costof equity capital on firm size, market beta, and a self. Abstract the purpose of this article is to identify the determinants of social and environmental disclosure and its relationship with the cost of equity.
The sample used is composed of 36 tunisian listed companies over the period 20012005. We also contribute to a strand of literature examining the link between disclosure and the cost of capital. Disclosure level and expected cost of equity capital citeseerx. Financial disclosure, corporate transparency, and innovation. An examination of analysts rankings of corporate disclosure and alternative methods of estimating expected cost of equity capital april 2000.
The impact of information disclosure quality on the cost. First, this attention to the combined impact of board characteristics and transparency level on corporate financing costs is a. The direct effect occurs because higher quality disclosures affect the firms assessed covariances with other firms cash flows, which is nondiversifiable. Board independence, voluntary disclosure, and the cost of. The effect of corporate social responsibility disclosure. To summarise, if accounting policy choice is correlated with both the dependent variable cost of equity capital, and disclosure level, but is not controlled for, then the coefficient on the disclosure level variable may be biased correlated omitted. Firmlevel tests of association between disclosure and cost of equity capital table 18. Botosan 2002 used the information disclosure index to empirically study the relationship between information disclosure level and cost of equity capital and obtained negative correlation between information disclosure level and cost of equity capital by the number of analysts tracking. Over the years, a growing interest in voluntary disclosure practices has been exhibited by many researchers. Purpose this paper aims to investigate the association between the level of voluntary disclosure and cost of equity capital coec. Ambiguous customer identity disclosure and the cost of.
The latter result is contrary to theory but is consistent with managers claims that greater timely disclosures may increase the cost of equity capital, possibly through increased stock price volatility. In this paper, we conjecture that the weak association between disclosure and cost of equity capital found in the literature botosan, 1997 can be caused by the highlevel corporate disclosure environment found in the united states. Agency costs of free cash flow and the effect of shareholder rights on the implied cost of equity capital volume 46 issue 1 kevin c. Effect of corporate governance attributes and disclosure level 562 our research differs from previous studies on several levels. Meanwhile, the cost of equity capital in this study is measured capital asset using pricing model capm. There are quite a few empirical studies that have dealt with the effect of disclosure on the cost of equity capital. Botosan c, plumlee m 2002 a reexamination of disclosure level and the expected cost of equity capital. The effect of disclosure level on the cost of equity. Disclosure, analyst forecast bias, and the cost of equity capital. Further reproduction prohibited without permission. Welker 1995 documents a negative association between disclosure levels and relative bidask spreads. At a conceptual level, cost of capital is only a price variable and, as. Pdf the relationship between disclosure and cost of equity capital has always.
This paper aims to investigate the association between the level of voluntary disclosure and cost of equity capital coec. In this paper we conjecture that the weak association between disclosure and cost of equity capital found in the literature botosan, 1997 can be caused by the high level corporate disclosure environment found in the us. The impact of voluntary impact of voluntary disclosure on. We find that the cost of equity capital decreases in the annual report disclosure level but increases in the level of timely disclosures. Botosan and plumlee 2005 report that some icc estimates are significantly. Pdf relationship between cost of equity capital and. This may be because my disclosure measure is limited. Disclosure level and the cost of equity capital semantic scholar. Voluntary disclosure and the cost of equity capital. Designmethodologyapproach two disclosure indices following botosan and hail are developed and applied in an ols regression on 95 listed companies from austria, germany. Disclosure and cost of equity capital in emerging markets. The effect of disclosure level on the cost of equity capital is a matter of considerable interest and importance to. The effect of disclosure level on the cost of equity capital.
The impact of the sarbanesoxley act sox on the cost of. Pdf relationship between cost of equity capital and voluntary. Ambiguous customer identity disclosure and the cost of equity. First, this attention to the combined impact of board characteristics and transparency level on corporate financing costs is a relatively new concern from. I develop a measure of disclosure level and generate a data set consisting of the disclosure scores for 247 manufacturing firms. Disclosure level and the cost of capital by christine. Disclosure level and the cost of equity capital semantic. In this paper i examine the association between disclosure level and the cost of equity capital by regressing firmspecific estimates of cost of equity capital on market beta, firm size and a self. Agency costs of free cash flow and the effect of shareholder rights on the implied cost of equity capital volume 46 issue 1 kevin. Societal information disclosure and the cost of equity. Abstractthe purpose of this article is to identify the determinants of social and environmental disclosure and its relationship with the cost of equity.
Disclosure incentives and effects on cost of capital around. Botosan 2002 used the information disclosure index to empirically study the relationship between information disclosure level and cost of equity capital and obtained negative correlationbetween information disclosure level and cost of equity capital by the number of analyststracking. The relationship between voluntary disclosure and financial. Annual report narratives and the cost of equity capital. Shareholder rights, financial disclosure and the cost of. Abstract the purpose of this study is to investigate the effect of corporate social responsibility disclosure and value based management on the cost of equity capital. Botosan, ca 1997 disclosure level and the cost of equity capital.
I find that the cost of equity capital estimates thus obtained are increasing in beta and decreasing in market value. Economic theory suggests that by increasing the level of corporate reporting firms not only increase their. Disclosure incentives and effects on cost of capital. However, i find no evidence of an association between my measure of disclosure level and cost of equity capital for firms with a high analyst following. We find that the relationship between financial disclosure and the cost of equity capital is magnified when combined with ic disclosure.
The effect of disclosure level on the cost of equity capital is a matter of considerable. Disclosure level and the cost of capital by christine botosan. Disclosure level and expected cost of equity capital. Transparency, firm characteristics and cost of equity. Firm size, disclosure and cost of equity capital, asian. Voluntary disclosure and the cost of capital greg clinch. The impact of voluntary disclosure on cost of equity capital. Conservatism, disclosure and the cost of equity capital. She uses a sample of 115 firms and measures cost of capital using a. Disclosure level and the cost of equity capital christine.
Using data for a sample of 125 uk firms, we find a negative relationship between the cost of equity capital and ic disclosure. This study uses manufacturing company consumer goods sector which is listed on indonesia stock exchange idx in 20162017. Botosan c, plumlee m, xie y 2004 the role of information. On the firm side the cost of equity capital is the cost the company to obtain external for funding. A reexamination of disclosure level and the expected cost. However, the relationship between disclosure level and cost of capital is not well established and has proved difficult for researchers to quantify. Using a disclosure scoring model this association is examined for 5 banks from europe, north america and australia. The relationship between disclosure and cost of equity capital has always been interesting not only for managers, but for investors as well. The magnitude of the difference in cost of equity capital between the most and least forthcoming firms is approximately onehalf to one percentage point, after controlling for market beta and firm size. Depending on the model used, relative percentage increases in the cost of equity capital average between 7 and. Explaining his finding, botosan 1997 argues that disclosure would reduce estimation risk, total risk of owning a stock, or asymmetric information. Despite this body of evidence, we might not observe the disclosureexternal financing linkage and the disclosurecost of capital relation outside the united states because of.
Botosan 1997 finds evidence that in the us market voluntary disclosure. Botosan and plumlee, 2002 regarding disclosure and cost of equity had found that there was a significant negative relationship between disclosure and cost of equity. Designmethodologyapproach two disclosure indices following botosan and hail are developed and applied in an ols regression on 95 listed companies from austria, germany, sweden, and denmark. As expected, we find that cost of equity capital is decreasing in annual report disclosure level.
The impact of voluntary disclosure on cost of equity. Different from prior studies that assume a unidirectional effect of disclosure level or quality on the cost of capital e. The explanation for this negative relationship is that higher disclosure reduces information asymmetry that leads to a reduction in transaction costs. If accounting policy choice is relevant, then the relationship between the cost of equity capital and disclosure is not monotonic. Disclosure quality, cost of capital, and investors welfare. First, cost of capital could increase with disclosure quality when new investment is sufficiently elastic.
Disclosure interactions and the cost of equity capital. Portfoliolevel tests of association between disclosure and cost of equity capital table 17. Botosan c 1997 disclosure level and the cost of equity capital. Botosan, c, plumlee, m 2002 a reexamination of disclosure level and the expected cost of equity capital. The relationship between disclosure quality and cost of equity capital is an important topic in todays economy. Disclosure, analyst forecast bias, and the cost of equity. The impact of information disclosure quality on the cost of. Empirical work on this link, however, is confronted with major methodological drawbacks neither disclosure level nor cost of capital can be observed. Prior evidence suggests that firms with providing more disclosures have a lower cost of capital e.
The effect of accounting restatements on earnings revisions. Feb 15, 2000 as expected, we find that cost of equity capital is decreasing in annual report disclosure level. An examination of analysts rankings of corporate disclosure and alternative methods of estimating expected cost of equity ca botosan, m plumlee. International differences in the cost of equity capital. Disclosure level and the cost of equity capital christine a. It is negative for aggressive firms, but in the case of conservative. An examination of analysts rankings of corporate disclosure number of pages. Bhattacharya 2003 proved that the lower of the cost of.
In any case, the inverse relationship between disclosure and cost of capital is expected. My disclosure index is based on the amount of voluntary information provided in the firms 1940. The effect of disclosure level on the cost of equity capital is a matter of considerable interest and importance to the financial reporting community. Botosan 1997 shows that among firms attracting a low analyst following, those that present higherquality disclosures benefit from lower levels of cost of capital. Dec 17, 2002 we find that the cost of equity capital decreases in the annual report disclosure level but increases in the level of timely disclosures.
Shareholder rights, financial disclosure and the cost of equity capital. However, the association between disclosure level and cost of equity capital is not well established and has been difficult to quantify. Second, there are plausible conditions under which disclosure quality reduces the welfare of current andor new investors. Botosan disclosure level and the cost of equity capital 325 in the cost of equity capital of 28 basis points, on average, for these firms. We show that, on average, accounting restatements lead to both decreases in expected future earnings and increases in the firms cost of equity capital. In general, economic theory and anecdotal evidence suggest a negative association. Disclosure level and the cost of equity capital jstor. Bhattacharya2003 proved that the lower of the cost of. A theory of voluntary disclosure and cost of capital. Cost of capital, strategic disclosures and accounting choice.
758 696 938 1612 398 1254 270 1022 749 453 894 395 1159 1295 1144 169 1417 729 365 1310 822 492 1137 1632 577 418 272 352 1113 616 917 8 1125 436 119 1441 520 730 346