I really wanted to like the movie as much as i did the book, and it was ok. The story is about 18yearold lina mayfleet and her friend doon harrows efforts to survive in a postapocalyptic underground city. One reason is that the mystery of ember is bigger than both lina and doon, and itll. The city of ember 2003 by jeanne duprau is the first science fiction novel in a series for young adult readers called the book of ember. Robert sutton from horn book magazine compared the novel to gathering blue by lois lowry, noting how the darkness of ember is essentially literal with. Exploitation is spreading through the city and the worst part of all of this the lights are failing. Doon and lina traded jobs in the book and the movie. Which is better the city of ember book or the movie. Creately diagrams can be exported and added to word, ppt powerpoint, excel, visio or any other document. For example, in the movie there were sul, a worker in the pipeworks that worked in there for his whole life.
Compare and contrast novel and film this chart provides a way for students to organize their observations about the movie. City of ember is a 2008 american science fiction adventure film based on the 2003 novel the city of ember by jeanne duprau. The moles have evolved into obese creatures with slimy tentacles surrounding their fangs, the. Robert sutton from horn book magazine compared the novel to gathering blue by lois lowry, noting how the. Naturally i wanted to see the movie, which had to be good since the book was so awesome nope. Rent city of ember 2008 on dvd and bluray dvd netflix. City of ember living underground could people really live underground. In literacy lounge we read a book called city of ember, when we finished reading it we had to wright a five paragraph essay about the city of ember. Theres more to a bottlecap than keeping liquid from leaking out of glass. Rather than just watching a movie, students will be able to analyze it effectively by comparing and contrasting it with the novel. Nickie will grow up to be one of the first citizens of the city of ember.
City of ember is a very clean movie in the sense that there are no foul words or crude elements. Novel study with questions, projects, and activities this huge 150 page the city of ember novel study package contains a fully integrated, creative, and comprehensive novel study on the the city of ember by jeanne duprau. I would rate them this because the book was a little more realistic than the movie. I know that this book, the city of ember is being turned into a major motion pictu. The city of ember compare and contrast by mya dubois on prezi. The city of ember the critically acclaimed noveldupraus electric debut that offers refreshingly clear writing and fascinating, original charactersis now in paperback. A gentle introduction to the idea of a dystopian future, ember is a sealed city built to protect a chosen few from a cataclysm. Mar 24, 2010 i dont remember there being a big idea to escape the city that they stumbled across, only the map the mayor does not end up eaten by a big mole thingy the characters go their own separate ways a lot more often, and are more reluctant to work with each other than is portrayed in the film. City of ember is a 2008 american science fiction adventure film based on the 2003 novel the. Imagine seeing character from a movie walking in a dark lonely hallway where you see a giant shadow of a mole trying to eat you.
The different relationships that lina has with her friends shed light on the nature of friendships which ones are genuine and which ones are simply convenient for the time being. The young protagonist, lina mayfleet, and her friend, doon harrow, manage to decode a. The city of ember book of ember paperback 14 may 20. Compare and contrast city of ember movie and book answers. The moles have evolved into obese creatures with slimy tentacles surrounding their fangs, the better to eat you with, my dear. Many hundreds of years ago, the city of ember was created by the builders to contain everything needed for human survival. The city of ember was old, and everything in it, including the power lines, was in need of repair. Ill probably forget some, but here are the ones i can think of. I am currently reading the city of ember aloud to my children. At moments city of ember suggests a mild satire of endofdays. My students love to watch movies after we read books.
Also lina and doon want mayor cole to reveal what he knows. Similar to suzanne martels the city under ground published in 1963, the story is about ember, an underground city that is slowly running out of power and supplies due to its aging. The book the city of ember was first published in 2003 and is the first. For generations, the people of the city of ember have flourished in an amazing world of glittering lights. Similar to suzanne martels the city under ground published in 1963, the story is about ember, an underground city that is slowly. Goodbye to the three electric lights in the ceiling that seemed. Discover the prophecy that started it all in this prequel to the the city of ember a modernday classic with over 4 million copies sold. May 14, 20 with the city of ember, jeanne duprau delivers a terrific read for 9 year olds. I liked the book city of ember better than the movie, because in the movie it changed up a lot of the parts i really liked. I think that this book is a graphic novel because it is not real.
Jeanne dupraus instant classic tells the story of the great, underground city of ember, designed as a last refuge for the human race. The story is about ember, a postapocalyptic underground city threatened by aging infrastructure and corruption. Free resources to use with the city of ember city of. The first book is the city of ember, second book is the people of sparks, the third book is the prophet of yonwood, the final book is the diampond of darkhold. Two hundred years later, the great lamps that light the city are beginning to flicker. At only 95 minutes, the movie feels as though it had been shredded in the editing room. City of ember tells of a city buried deep within the earth, as a shelter for human survivors after something awful happened upstairs, im not clear exactly what. Mar 25, 2017 naturally i wanted to see the movie, which had to be good since the book was so awesome nope. I read the book the city of ember by jeanne duprau, and watched the 2008 movie production city of ember. Harry potter and the philosophers stone and new line cinemas the. This book was made into a movie in the fall of 2008. Every 5 paragraph essay has their own purpose of being written, as an example mine was comparing the book and movie of city of ember.
Jun 10, 2011 i read the city of ember several years ago so i had to quickly read it again to refresh my memory a bit. I appreciate all of the excellent imagery the author uses and i have bought many many copies over the years and have given them as gifts to others. Also in the book the city of ember one of the main themes is person vs person. Movie segments to assess grammar goals contains a series of movie segments and activities to assess or practice grammar points through fun, challenging exercises. Even in ember, a dark city that is rapidly falling apart, friendship seems to be the key to getting by. Get an answer for what are a few objects that represent the characters and themes in jeanne dupraus the city of ember. What is the conflict in the story the city of ember.
I am expecting a large class for the coming year and it would be great if i had a copy of the city of ember to give each student within the first month of school. Great culminating project ideas for a literature study of the city of ember. Needless, to say the city of ember could be engulfed by darkness, if a solution is not made soon. Now, two teenagers in a race against time, must search ember for clues that will unlock the ancient mystery of the city s existence, and help the citizens escape before the lights go out forever.
Kenan described it as exactly the kind of movie that i wanted to. This is the first book of ember in the authors series. The city of ember is a postapocalyptic science fiction novel by jeanne duprau that was. The best things about this are scenes of the ominous.
The city of ember is a postapocalyptic primarytomiddlegrade science fiction novel by jeanne duprau that was published in 2003. Giant killer moles and humungous moths and beetles. The city of ember 2003, a young adult novel by jeanne duprau, is a post apocalyptic story with a twist. This isnt exactly the ember i read about in jeanne dupraus novel. What is difference between movie and book city of ember answers. There are some differences between the book and the film as always, doon and lina are great characters and their quest to find a way out of ember is interesting as they work out the parchment which was left by the builders. The city of ember my students love to watch movies after we read books. Here you will find the movie segments, the lesson plans, printable worksheets with answer key for each activity, and the tips to develop your own grammar activities with the dvds you.
On the positive side, it was a pretty entertaining movie to watch. Discover the prophecy that started it all in this prequel to the the city of embera modernday classic with over 4 million copies sold. Goodbye to the map of the city of ember in its scarred wooden frame and the cabinet whose shelves held the book of numbers, the book of letters, and the book of the city of ember. Might have involved radiation, since giant mutant bees, moles and beetles are roaming around down there. The story begins in the mid twentyfirst century following. Lina and doon are citizens of the city of ember, a city surrounded by darkness. What is the difference between the book the city of ember and the movie the city of ember. In 2008, the book was adapted into a film by walden media and playtone. This chart provides a way for students to organize their observations about the movie version of the novel the city of ember, by jeanne duprau. The city of ember was built as a last refuge for the human race. The city of ember is a postapocalyptic science fiction novel by jeanne duprau that was published in 2003. These were terrible moments for the people of ember.
Asked in horror, horror and suspense movies, stephen king. The city of ember is such an enjoyable, imaginative, wonderful book. Or will it be up to lina and doon to rediscover the lost exit to the surface. Coronavirus pandemic the cast of the movie contagion. The city of ember is, you guessed it, about a city nameddrumroll, please ember. What are a few objects that represent the characters and. I bought the city of ember after i watched the film adaptation a few weeks ago, which was a good movie, i liked the story. The city of ember is a postapocalyptic primarytomiddlegrade science fiction novel by. Use pdf export for high quality prints and svg export for large sharp images or embed your diagrams anywhere with the creately viewer. But this is just the start of something new, the rest of the citizens in ember still have to get out, but will they trust lina and doon.
So now and then the lights would flicker and go out. The city of ember is a science fiction novel by jeanne duprau recommended for children ages 9 to and published in 2003. In the end, lina, doon and poppy all find the way out of ember. Now a major motion picture starring bill murray, tim robbins, martin landau, saoirse ronan, and harry treadaway. They got the basic plot, but i enjoyed the book a lot more than the movie. Directed by gil kenan, the film stars saoirse ronan, harry treadaway, bill murray, mackenzie crook, martin landau, mary kay. There are significant differences and it is great to see students identify those. Similar to suzanne martels the city under ground published in 1963, the story is about ember, an underground city that is slowly running out of power and supplies due to its aging infrastructure. But why call it that instead of lina and doons excellent adventure or lina in emberland. My students will need 30 paperback copies of the book the city of ember, by jeanne duprau. Rent city of ember 2008 starring saoirse ronan and harry treadaway on dvd and bluray. Poppy chowed up the instructions in the book and the movie. I read the city of ember several years ago so i had to quickly read it again to refresh my memory a bit.
Book to movie the city of ember concerning writing. May 27, 2012 what is difference between movie and book city of ember. One reason is that the mystery of ember is bigger than both lina and doon, and itll take them working together to figure it out. Compare and contrast novel and film this chart provides a way for students to organize their observations about the movie version of the novel the city of ember, by jeanne duprau. The city of ember is a fantastic read aloud and it is always a great activity to follow up with the movie. Conclusion in the end i think that the book was much better than the movie because of little mistakes and how different that movie was than the book. This tiein edition ofthe city of emberfeatures a movie art cover and an 8page photo insert. The city of ember is, you guessed it, about a city nameddrumroll, pleaseember. As a reward for my students we watched the feature film the last week of school. Sul is the one with the orange shirt trying to fix the turbine of the generator. The adaptation really skimmed a lot of what made city of ember so good the tension, the mystery, the hope and faith. One of the first things we learn about lina is that she loves to run. This underground city did work for about 200 yearsbut now the storerooms were becoming skim and the crops are damaged.
I have personally read all three books in this series and highly recommend it to my students. After learning about reallife underground cities, students are invited to design their own underground city, tackling both traditional. City of ember book was very different from the movie. Goodbye to the cabinet drawers labeled new paper and old paper.
The city and its rulers show the failure of humanity, especially the failure of big government. With saoirse ronan, toby jones, bill murray, david ryall. I have used this successfully in my grade class for several years. The anticipation of the movie coming out will definitely excite them to read their book. While watching the movie, i jotted down similarities and differences, and there were many more differences than similarities. Another novel jeanne wrote was called car trouble which is not part of the city of ember series. What is difference between movie and book city of ember. But ember s once powerful generator is failing and the great lamps that illuminate the city are starting to flicker.
Directed by gil kenan, the film stars saoirse ronan, harry treadaway, bill murray, mackenzie crook, martin landau, mary kay place, toby jones and tim robbins. City of ember navigating ember using clues from the book, students navigate a map of ember to steer lina to her sister, poppy. At the same time, the city in city of ember is a very dirty, decaying, human dystopia. Doon and lina are trying to get out of the big hole. This is a main theme because lina is trying to find a way out while mayor cole only want to find a way out for him self. About a month ago, i read the book and loved it, and you know what that means. If youve seen the movie, its worth reading the book because not everything that happened in the movie, happens in the book for example. The main characters, doon and lina, looked as if they had stepped out of the book, especially lina. Yep, i had to go and see if there was a movie adaptation.
1632 1296 1505 155 22 71 811 1119 1613 526 693 1391 1322 1518 1604 71 989 940 1359 478 648 494 135 430 30 728 373 1078